NEW AND IN VIEW
Although we had no information other than that generally released to the public on new items from Frog, our local stockist has recently received supplies of their latest releases, the Heinkel 111 H1/H6 and Chance Vought Corsair F4U-1D.
We purchased one of each to see what was what and the result is rather mixed feelings.
The Heinkel suffers from some of the same production errors. Considering the wealth of very accurate and comprehensive detail available on this aircraft it should be absolutely spot on to make it worth best part of a Pound. It checks out quite well on scale and shape apart from wing tips and tail which are slightly too round and can be reshaped easily. Surface detail is good but once again much is lost filling bad gaps in the wing root fit and engine nacelles. Fuselage halves need some fitting and the odd insert to the fuselage to enable the alternative H6 version to be made is a poor fit. The transparencies could be much thinner and clearer and the windows for the gondola are merely blobs of clear plastic which sit in a hole. The port lower wing need packing towards the tip or it sinks below the edge of the aileron, and though the trailing edges of the wings are much thinner, the effort has been too much for the production method and there is considerable mould sink on these surfaces.
The undercarriage is fragile and much too long, even if it is intended to represent the aircraft in flight with undercarriage lowered and it is not easy to reduce to correct length, due to the rather complex structure - this is a rather bad fault which needs attention. Cockpit detail is inadequate, but fair as far as it goes. Decals are good quality but the swastika off register. Box art acceptable and attractive but greens depicted too light.
The IPMS magazine, JUNE 1972. Vol. 9 No. 6
Model Enthusiast
A pair of "standards" from Frog
One of the more remarkable aspects of the modelling scene is the fact that, despite the proliferation of kits of World War II's "standards", some of the true immortals of that conflict are still represented by only one kit, or by kits that are so inaccurate that they are simply not worth purchasing. One such aircraft is perhaps best known of all the Luftwaffe's wartime bombers, the shapely Heinkel He 111. There has been only one good kit of this aircraft on the market and this represents a late production variant and is therefore not truly representative of the notorious instrument of the Blitz in which most UK modellers are interested. Frog has now filled this gap, and happily its 1/72nd scale offering, which may be completed as an He 111H-1 bomber or He 111H-6 torpedo-bomber, is, if not faultless, a very good one.
It is both accurate in outline and finely detailed, but it falls down in respect of component fit. Filling is necessary around the wing root and engine nacelle joints, while some of the fuselage transparencies are too small and do not fill the apertures completely. On the other hand, the He 111's characteristic, enormous and oddly-shaped nose transparency is handled very well indeed, and reveals plenty of good cockpit detail. The decals provide markings for an He 111H-1 of the Gruppenstab of II/KG 55 and for an He 111H-6 of II/KG 26, and as is usual with Frog kits, these are excellent in quality. The same may be said for the colour scheme drawings on the box. A good kit of a most important aeroplane, at 78p in the UK it is well worth the money.
Frog's other "standard" is a 1/72nd scale kit of the F4U Corsair which makes up into a really good, accurate, and finely-detailed model which is easy to assemble providing some care is taken with the wing root joint. Decals are provided for a Corsair IV of No 1842 Squadron, Fleet Air Arm, and for an F4U-1D of the Royal New Zealand Air Force, and the usual excellent colour scheme drawing is provided. It is certainly good value at its UK price of 21p, and our only reservation is engendered by doubts concerning a sizeable market for a 1/72nd kit of this aircraft, as most modellers who want to include this war-plane in their collections will surely have already made it. After all, there have been so many kits of the Corsair available for so long.
Air Enthusiast 1972-08 Vol3 No2
Modelling world
New Frog kits
A VERY happy event for modellers has recently taken place with the first releases of new kits from Frog after its troubles. Although I have harshly criticised certain aspects of individual Frog kits, as well as given praise where due, I for one would have been extremely sorry if the name of Frog had disappeared from the shelves of our model shops. Frog was the pioneer of the plastic kit, with its far-sighted pre-war Penguin series, and its demise would have been a tragedy. Frog has always deserved praise for its choice of kit subjects, which in the past have included many interesting, if possibly less-popular subjects instead of concentrating only on "dead-cert" commercial lines. These have included such kits as the Wyvern, Tupolev SB-2, Vimy, Vampire FB5, Southern Cross (Fokker FVII-3m), Ta-152, etc, which were not likely to have been produced by the majority of manufacturers. Frog has shown commendable courage in some of its kit subjects and I hope that modellers will give it the support it deserves. On the other side of the coin I hope that Frog will continue to produce kits of the more unusual aviation subjects as well as the more commercial types, and ensure the accuracy and moulding quality of its kits.
The first of the new Frog kits is a Heinkel He111H-1 or H-6. These marks of the famous German bomber were much used. The H-1 was a standard bomber variant and the H-6 a torpedo-bomber version familiar to Allied convoys. These versions both had the characteristic, long, glazed upper gunner's windshield which was so much a hallmark of the Heinkel. I never could understand why Airfix chose the H-20 version for its kit, which was not so widely used and featured a powered mid-upper turret in place of the original, unless it was considered that the rotating turret would appeal more to the schoolboy market.
Frog's Heinkel is generally accurate, although certain corrections are necessary. The shape of the fin, rudder and tailplane require attention. The fin and rudder are too rounded, and need to be more pointed. The tailplane has a somewhat kinked appearance on the leading edges and needs smoothing out. This latter looks like a tooling error, but both this and the former are easily corrected. The wings are beautifully contoured, with the characteristically deep wing root sections and convincingly thin wing tips. The fuselage is slightly slimmer than in the Airfix interpretation and it is difficult to say which is correct in depth without knowing the dimensions, but the Frog model looks in proportion in relation to the various components. The engine nacelles look accurate in shape except for the radiators, which are too deep—the latter components could also have been improved with some internal detail, instead of having a large tunnel straight through. The worst features of this kit are the undercarriage units, which are too long and stilty. It is good to see delicate moulding, but in this case the legs and stays are too flimsy and do not give the appearance of being able to take the weight of a fully-bombed-up Heinkel. I modified my Frog Heinkel by adapting the main undercarriage leg units from an Airfix Dornier Do217 kit, which are .about the right length and more substantial, by marrying them to the existing rear stays in the Frog kit after suitably cutting down these latter items.
I also think that the front gunner's "bubble" gun position is a little small in diameter, and this was replaced by a B-29 barbette sighting blister, which is slightly larger.
Cockpit detail is excellent and the very clear extensive glazing gives ample scope for the modeller who wants to add to the internal equipment.
Parts provided in the kit give alternatives for the standard bomber or torpedo bomber. For the latter, special carriers and two torpedoes are included. The special rear gun installation fitted in the extreme rear fuselage of the H-6 is also provided as an alternative.
Transfers supplied are for two versions, a standard Battle of Britain H-1 based at Villacoublay, near Paris, during the summer of 1940 and operated by II Gruppe/ KG55, and an H-6 torpedo bomber of 5 Staffel/W Gruppe/KG26 "Lowen" operating in the Mediterranean area during 1942. With the corrections and alterations carried out, Frog's Heinkel He111 makes up into a fine model and is, I think, the best yet of this famous aircraft. It is bound to prove very popular with modellers. Cost of the kit is 78p.
AIRCRAFT ILLUSTRATED 1972-08
KITS AMD MODELS
Frog: 1:72 scale He 111 and Corsair
AS we close for press we've received— but not assembled—two new Frog releases, a Heinkel He 111- H1, with optional markings and armament for the H6, and a Corsair F4U-ID. The He 111 differs from the Airfix version and depicts a Battle of Britain machine in its HI form. It looks fine on a 'dry run' and the parts fit well together. The Corsair, at first sight, duplicates the other Corsairs available but this one wins by being really flush and smooth, just like the real thing, rather than peppered with rivets. It comes with imaginative markings too, for the RNZAF. or 1842 Sqn FAA in 1945. This appears to be a very accurate model. The He 111 costs 80p plus 15p postage, and the Corsair is 21 p plus 5p postage. Jones Bros of Chiswick hold stocks and sent our samples.
C.O.E.
Airfix magazine 1972-06 Vol.13 No.10
KIT COMMENT
TWO POPULAR LUFTWAFFE AIRCRAFT MODELLED BY FROG
MESSERSCHMITT Me 262 AND HEINKEL He 111 RELEASED
Models of Luftwaffe aircraft are always popular particularly in the United States. Sales of Bf 109s are double anything else released by kit manufacturers and other well known types such as the Fw 190 come a close second. Two models on the periphery of popularity are the He 111 and Me 262, one because it was the best-known German medium bomber and the other as it was the first operational jet fighter in the world. Frog have long wanted to expand their range to include more Luftwaffe aircraft and now with the release of these two new models have provided us with kits that are a little more accurate than their contemporaries but could still do with some improvement.
The Airfix Me 262 was produced about ten years ago and has long needed something of greater accuracy to replace it. The later Revell model was much better but lacked some refinements, particularly regarding the cockpit canopy and internal detail.
The Frog offering provides this this but although a high standard in outline accuracy has been achieved the mouldings and fit of several components leave something to be desired.
Viewed from above there appears to be no problem but if the kit is stuck together without adding body putty the undersides of the wings and engine nacelles are not so good. Any discerning model maker will overcome the badly fitting parts in a few minutes by adding filler but the fact remains that more attention should have been given to these components.
Apart from this criticism there is little to fault the model. It has, in the main, been delicately treated as far as panel lines go, the cockpit canopy is excellent and the nose and tail cones in the jets have been added satisfactorily. There's no detail in the cockpit apart from a pilot's seat but at least the armoured head rest has been provided so that externally, the model looks complete.
The Me 262 undercarriage is a good one. The angle of the main legs has been achieved correctly so has the thickness and weight of the main wheels. We cut off the bulbous ends to the undercarriage legs over which the wheels are supposed to clip as these do not help in the final appearance of the model. The two bombs provided in the kit looked rather poor at first glance and were replaced by spares taken from another model.
As usual Frog's decal sheet is first rate. Two aircraft are featured, the first being an Me 262A-la belonging to III/JG7 when based at Kaltenkir-chen/Holstein in February 1945 and the other an Me 262A -2a of 1/KG51 operating from Achmer in the same period. The box art is good, the instruction sheet easy to understand. In fact the whole constructional work in this kit was a simple task and places the model amongst the few which can be recommended for the beginner to plastic aircraft kit modelling.
Should the beginner want to make the model he should take one word of warning in that a large amount of added weight is needed in the nose to keep the model on its undercarriage. The whole forward part of the model needs filling with lead and plasticine. Alternatively Frog have provided parts so that the undercarriage can be placed in the 'up* position.
AWKWARD UNDERCARRIAGE
Modellers can produce either a Heinkel He 111 H-1 or the H-6 model from the larger of the two recent Frog releases. Whereas the Me 262 was simple to construct, the bomber is a little more difficult. It too has its problems as far as accuracy goes, particularly in the undercarriage, fin and rudder and front gunner's cupola.
It is pleasing to note that Frog have provided us with the more popular of the He 111 series. The Airfix model is of the H-20 sporting a dorsal turret and very difficult to convert into the version having the long canopy with the upper gunner's position partially exposed. At least we can be happy in that both companies have different variants ©n the market and it seems to us that a little cross kitting would not go amiss.
Although generally accurate in outline, the shape of the He Ill's fin and rudder appears to be too rounded. A study of available photographs indicates that this component was more pointed than that supplied in the kit and at the same time is possibly too shallow in height. Although difficult to correct, this feature is completely overshadowed by the obviously inaccurate undercarriage. It seems that original plans must have been consulted of the aircraft in the air as the oleo legs are extended in such a way that the aircraft is a full quarter inch higher off the ground than it should be.
We made up our sample using the undercarriage provided in the kit but there seems to be no reason why the legs from the Airfix model could not be substituted given time and patience to get them to fit correctly.
The detail in the cockpit is excellent. This is lacking in the Airfix model and because of the amount of glazing much can be seen from outside. Frog have provided all we need here but again one of the components needs a certain amount of modification. This is the nose gun position. Being too small and slightly too rounded it is difficult to modify but looking through the spares box the idea of using a B-29 side cupola comes to mind as a suitable alternative.
Two versions of the He 111 are provided in the Frog model. The most attractive to the modeller is possibly the H-6 which was used as an anti-shipping torpedo bomber in both the Mediterranean and against the Arctic convoys. Parts are provided for this or an aircraft of the well-known H-1 variant used by most Staffeln during the Battle of Britain period. For the latter the decal sheet features an aircraft operated by II Gruppe/KG55 based at Villacoublay in 1940 whilst the torpedo bomber is represented by markings for 5 Staffel/II Gruppe/KG26 'Lowen' which operated in the Mediterranean during 1942. Providing the model maker is prepared to spend some time in slightly changing the various inaccurate parts on this He 111 there is no reason why he should not end up with a really first class model. It is true that the Frog offering is slightly less accurate in outline than the Airfix model but at least we can be pleased in the fact that it is now possible to make the H-1, H-6 and H-20 variants in 1:72nd scale.
Aviation News Vol 1 Num 7 18 - 31 August 1972
Letters to the editor
CORRECTING THE FROG HEINKEL He 111
Apart from some inaccuracies in the shape of the tail surfaces and an over-extended undercarriage, the recent Frog kit of the Heinkel He 111H to 1:72 scale can be made into a fair model of this famous WWII bomber. By attending to the latter error, a much more pleasing model will result.
Having assembled the wings and fuselage as per instructions, do not proceed with the fitting of the engine nacelles. Cement the landing gear in place according to the sketch. Part 16 represents the oleo struts which have to be slightly inclined to the rear. The next step is to stick part 18 with its upper end into the corners formed by the bottom of the wheel well and the oleos. Trim off the end of part 17 and cement it in place, remembering to position it correctly at the points indicated on the other two parts. The rear ends fit into the corners of the wheel well. With the mainwheels added, the Heinkel sits correctly.
Dipl.-Ing. Karl Kossler,
3301 Weddel, West Germany
Aviation News Vol 1 Num 11 13-26 October 1972
KIT COMMENT
DOUBLE HEINKEL
One of the most popular conversions by modellers of World War 2 German aircraft has been that of the He 111Z heavy glider tug. This marriage of two He 111 bomber fuselages with a fifth engine added is relatively simple, although the sanding of the extra wing aerofoil section from solid wood or plastic can be time-consuming. This problem has now been remedied by Airmodel kit No 149, which provides all the modeller needs for this weird aeronautical contraption.
Those new to conversions will also benefit by using a pair of Frog He 111s, which of course, provide the 'glasshouses' on top of the fuselage, which the earlier Airfix He 111H-20 does not.
The kit contains six parts, including two longitudinal strengthened for the wing section, an airscrew and an engine. Instructions are straightforward and the job requires only sticking the new parts together and cutting off the wings of the two Frog kits. The spares box could well come up with another Heinkel propellor and spinner, as the Airmodel offering needs the rear of the blades building up with body putty and is not as well moulded as the units on the Frog kit.
To round off this striking model, one could make an interesting diorama with perhaps, ground figures 'hooking on' a pair of Gotha Go 242 gliders, which are also obtainable in the Airmodel range.
Aviation News Vol 1 Num 14 24 November - 7 December 1972
NEW TO YOU?
New aircraft releases reviewed by 'SCALE MODELS9 staff, show new kits of popular subjects
TWO NEW FROG kits have been released by ROVEX/TRIANG, these are the F4U Corsair (W.W.2) and the Heinkel He.111 H-1 -H-6.
FROG's other new kit is a 1/72nd version of one of the Luftwaffe's most well-known bombers, the Heinkel He. 111.
The kit represents (according to the box top) both H-1 and H-6 variants. Actually, the kit will not portray an H-1 100 per cent due to the difference in the lower ventral gondola. Checking the kit with our drawings (Planpack 2926, price 50p from the editorial offices) several differences become obvious, the model nacelles and exhaust system differ and some outlines of wing and tail show discrepancies.
The somewhat tricky nose transparency has been moulded extremely well, in three parts. Joint is horizontal and with a separate nose bubble does away with any unsightly joins which are often tricky to remove from transparencies. As usual with FROG, surface detail is confined to lines as opposed to rivets, and this always looks much better. The model portrays the H-6 variant best, a choice of underbelly pans being provided, plus two torpedoes. Noticeable omissions are any form of grille in the intakes under the nacelles, which are easily corrected by a piece of plastic card with a layer of stocking to represent the mesh.
After studying our completed model one may be inclined to think the undercarriage legs are too long, they are not incorrect but have been moulded in the 'in flight' configuration. Why this has been done is a mystery, but it is easy to shorten them before cementing to engine nacelles. Detail parts are well moulded, cockpit detail is good, as are the various types of machine guns. Transparencies fit well and are very clear and crisp. FROG have provided the modeller with all the aerials usually associated with the type as well as- the rudder/fin horns.
Fit of wings to fuselage utilised a spar, but regrettably there were quite a few gaps left to be filled with putty, perhaps a one-piece lower half for the wings would have helped.
The excellent decal sheet is very good and naturally offers a choice of markings for both H-1 and H-6 versions including swastikas. Very good value for money is represented by this Heinkel at 81 p.
Scale Models No.36 1972 SEPTEMBER Vol.3. No.09
|